Concerned Parkdale Endorses PCLS Member-Nominated Directors

In the lead up to tomorrow’s AGM, Concerned Parkdale is thrilled to endorse the following 6 people to run for positions on the PCLS Board of Directors (in alphabetical order):

  1. beth long
  2. Dave Nisker
  3. Diane Rajaram
  4. Gita Madan
  5. Joanna Mullen
  6. Oriel Varga

Here are their bios!

beth long

  • beth long is a resident of Parkdale who moved from Vancouver to article at PCLS in 2000-2001. She spent the next seven years in the community legal clinic system, working as a staff lawyer in four separate clinics (Mississauga, Bracebridge, Neighbourhood Legal and West Toronto). Currently, she is a research lawyer at the Human Rights Legal Support Centre, where she has worked since 2008. Informed and motivated in large part by her own lived-experience, beth’s past efforts as an activist have focused on campaigns to reduce the harms associated with sexual violence, poverty, addiction, homelessness, sex trade work, mental illness, policing and transphobia, among others. beth is passionate about the legal clinic system in Ontario, and she is committed to preserving and enhancing community-based access to legal services for the residents of Parkdale and Swansea who live in poverty. She strongly believes that PCLS’s position on the GTA Transformation proposal must originate in and be shaped as much as possible by the people who actually need and use its services. To that end, as a member of the PCLS Board, beth would work hard to create opportunities for the meaningful participation of community members in decisions concerning the delivery of clinic law services.

Dave Nisker

  • David Nisker is a 3rd year law student and recent graduate of the Parkdale Community Legal Services student intensive program in the Housing Division. He also worked at the clinic following his placement until early September, 2014. He currently resides in the clinic’s catchment area, and has partaken in many community initiatives surrounding the tenant rights. He also organizes with the Network for the Elimination of Police Violence and the Stop Racial Profiling committee of the Law Union. David recognizes that despite recent turmoil inside of PCLS, and with plans to close clinics, that we all believe that PCLS is a very important place for the residents of Parkdale. He believes that it is important to strengthen community legal clinics across the city and province by building on 40+ years of achievements and lessens. As a prospective Board member, David is interested in improving the student, staff, and client experiences at PCLS as well as the clinic’s overall efficacy. His business background and his valued current relationships and experiences at the clinic give him a great balance and perspective for serving on the Board of Directors.

Diane Rajaram

  • TBA

Gita Madan

  • Gita Madan is both a resident of and an employee in the Parkdale community. She is running for the Board of Directors because she believes that she is very well positioned to represent the interests of community members, particularly low-income residents who rely on the services of PCLS. Gita is a high school teacher, with a specialization in the area of Urban Education. She is currently a graduate student at the University of Toronto (OISE), where she studies the impacts of changes in school disciplinary policy on the most marginalized students in our education system. Gita is also very involved in the community and active in a number of local organizations and grassroots initiatives. This includes working as a food literacy educator at FoodShare, serving on the organizing collective of the Toronto Time Bank, and as a member of CLAY, a collective of legal-minded individuals who use popular education to engage the public in legal education.

Joanna Mullen

  • I have resided in Parkdale since 2012. I articled at Parkdale Community Legal Services from 2012-2013. I now work as a staff lawyer at Unison Health and Community Services, an organization that serves the community in the former city of York. As a resident of Parkdale, I am aware of the changes within the community due to gentrification. deportation, and poverty. I am concerned about how these changes are impacting the clients of PCLS. I hope that as a Board Member I can listen to the concerns of Parkdale residents and the staff at PCLS to ensure that the clinic continues to work to achieve justice and equality for all.

Oriel Varga

  • As a Board member, I bring with me a wealth of experience. I have an extensive background in organizing campaigns and creating grassroots projects. As a student in Workers’ Rights Division at PCLS, I worked closely with the Parkdale community and the Workers’ Action Centre. Today, I continue to work on issues impacting Parkdale. Most recently, I have been organizing to oppose the GTA Transformation Proposal. This plan threatens to close 13-14 community clinics for three mega-centres. As a PCLS board member, I will work hard to ensure PCLS (and 13 other clinics) remains open. I aim to bridge the gap between the board and staff and make sure the PCLS board listens to the Parkdale community. I will ensure PCLS is a leading edge legal clinic with a philosophy of community-based lawyering, rooted in the Parkdale community, for the next 40 years!

We note that, pursuant to PCLS Bylaws, all six PCLS members above were nominated by two PCLS members each before 5PM on Thurs, Nov 13. Each nominee received confirmation from PCLS of the timely submission of their nomination packages (both the nominations and the consents to the nominations).

We look forward to voting in these six incredible community members and advocates at the AGM tomorrow (7PM, Mon, Nov 17 at Bonar-Parkdale Presbyterian Church)!

We also note that, according to the notice that some PCLS members received from the current PCLS Board, the three Board-nominated nominees are:

  1. David Gellman
  2. Mercedes Perez
  3. Noah Aiken-Klar

Note that the above list no longer includes Namgyal Dolker, whom the Board nominated on Oct 29; David Gellman appears to have been now nominated by the Board in Namgyal’s stead.

If you are a PCLS member who has not yet received your notice of the AGM, please contact Robert Routh at PCLS: 416-531-2411 x 224 / routhr@lao.on.ca.

Reminder: AGM on Mon, Nov 17 at Bonar-Parkdale Church

Update: You can download here a copy of the notice that PCLS members began receiving today about next Monday’s AGM.

PCLS will be having its AGM on Monday, Nov 17 at 7PM at  Bonar-Parkdale Presbyterian Church.

If you aren’t already a member, make sure you submit your membership application by Tues, Nov 11 if you want to vote at the AGM. Encourage your friends and neighbours to become PCLS members too!

If you don’t know if you’re a member or not or if you’ve not yet received notice from PCLS about the AGM, contact Robert Routh at PCLS: 416-531-2411 x 224 / routhr@lao.on.ca

On Monday, we will confirm the election of the following member-nominated Directors:

  1. Diane Rajaram
  2. Joanna Mullen
  3. Dave Nisker
  4. Oriel Varga

We will also confirm the election of the following Board-nominated Directors:

  1. Noah Aiken-Klar
  2. Namgyal Dolker
  3. Mercedes Perez

Right now, this is the PCLS Board:

  1. Andrea Margles: amargles@krmc-law.com
  2. Amar Bhatia: abhatia@osgoode.yorku.ca
  3. David Gellman: David@davidgellman.com
  4. Desiree Warner: desmwarner@gmail.com
  5. Faisal Bhabha: fbhabha@osgoode.yorku.ca
  6. Jen Danch: jen.danch@gmail.com
  7. Mercedes Perez: mperez@swadron.com
  8. Noah Aiken-Klar: naikenklar@otf.ca
  9. Richard Haigh: rhaigh@osgoode.yorku.ca
  10. Shelley Gavigan: gavigan@osgoode.yorku.ca
  11. Two PCLS staff – non-voting
  12. One Osgoode/PCLS student – non-voting

We were glad to learn on Friday that the PCLS Board has postponed its vote on the Transformation Project from late 2014 until February 2015 (exact date and process to be announced by PCLS). This is a great win! We look forward to continuing the dialogue about how to ensure clinic users and community members guide conversations about the provision of legal aid services. Only your presence and contributions can ensure we have meaningful community consultation.

See you Monday!

PCLS Board Will Not Vote on Transformation Project until February 2015

Update: You can download here a copy of the notice confirming the new date for the Transformation vote.

Great news! The PCLS Board has announced that it will be postponing its decision on the GTA Transformation’s Vision Report (i.e. whether or not to close 16 Toronto community legal clinics and replace them with 3 mega centres) until February 2015!

We look forward to working with the PCLS Board in the intervening months to ensure that the perspectives of clinic users and community members guide conversations about how their legal aid clinics should provide legal aid services. This adjournment represents an opportunity to hold meaningful, accessible, and transparent consultations with community members about the how legal aid clinics can best serve users.

Stay tuned for updates on how this postponement is affecting other GTA clinics!

How to Become a PCLS Member

Becoming a voting member of PCLS is easy! Here’s what you do:

  1. Fill out the membership application form, which you can download here.
  2. Submit your completed membership form to PCLS by:
    1. Emailing it in:
    2. Faxing it in: 416-531-0885; or
    3. Dropping it off at PCLS front desk; or
    4. Mailing it in: 1266 Queen Street West, Toronto, Ontario M6K 1L3.
  3. Retain a copy of your completed membership form for your own records.

That’s it!

Note: if you want to vote in an election at a PCLS annual meeting, you have to submit your membership application at least five days before the election date.

PCLS Members “Take Back” Their Legal Clinic

Last week, Parkdale Community Legal Services (PCLS) attempted to hold its Annual General Meeting (AGM), which it had adjourned from June 2014. This is our reportback from that meeting on Wednesday, Oct 29.

The meeting concluded with PCLS agreeing to the following:

  • The PCLS Board will resume its AGM on Monday, Nov 17 at 7PM at a location that it will announce.
  • The PCLS Board will provide proper and timely notice for the Nov 17 meeting to PCLS members.
  • The PCLS Board will accept for candidacy those board nominations that PCLS had initially declined to consider.
  • The PCLS Board will accept for candidacy new board nominations for up to two business days before Nov 17.
  • The PCLS Board will register any new membership applications it has not yet registered.
  • The PCLS Board of Directors will not meet prior to this meeting on Nov 17.

Meanwhile, at this same meeting, PCLS members elected these seven people to the Board:

  1. Noah Aiken-Klar
  2. Diane Rajaram
  3. Namgyal Dolker
  4. Joanna Mullen
  5. Dave Nisker
  6. Mercedes Perez
  7. Oriel Varga

Background

The PCLS Board first held its AGM in June 2014. It sought to resume this AGM on Oct 29. However, the PCLS Board did not fully inform its membership of this new date. Word nonetheless spread about the meeting; approximately 35 PCLS members attended the meeting on Oct 29.

As soon as the meeting commenced, the membership questioned the PCLS board about the lack of notice. Despite these inquiries, the Board officially commenced the meeting.

After approving financial statements, the PCLS Board moved to deal with other AGM business.

Several members then duly moved and seconded a motion to elect the following individuals for to the PCLS Board:

  1. Diane Rajaram
  2. Joanna Mullen
  3. Dave Nisker
  4. Oriel Varga

Some of these nominees are known to be against the GTA Transformation Project’s Vision Report, which is the proposal that would close 13-14 legal clinics in the GTA and replace them with 3 mega-service centres.

As per the PCLS Bylaws, nomination applications for all four nominations had been submitted to the Board at least two days before Wed, Oct 29.

However, the PCLS Board ruled the nominations by the members “out of order.” The PCLS Board claimed that the nominations should have been submitted two days before the July meeting, not the October meeting.

Meanwhile, the Board sought to elect the following nominees, whom the Board had gathered itself, through its internal membership committee:

  1. Noah Aiken-Klar
  2. Namgyal Dolker
  3. Mercedes Perez

The members declined to vote-in these nominees, at which point the Board moved to adjourn the meeting. The members voted against the motion to adjourn the meeting, but the Board said the meeting was over. The Board left the room.

The PCLS members resumed the meeting with their own chair. The members proceeded with the Board elections. Halfway through the elections, the PCLS Board returned to announce that it would hold an election meeting on Monday, November 17th and that it would give due notice to all members.

The members in attendance requested ten minutes to finish the ongoing elections. The Board reiterated that the meeting was over and that the membership was no longer welcome in the clinic.

In response, one member said, “PCLS belongs to Parkdale, this is our clinic, we are not leaving, we are taking back our clinic.”

After continued pressure from the Board to leave the clinic, the membership finished their  elections outside, with quorum still present. In total, the following people were elected to the PCLS Board:

  1. Noah Aiken-Klar
  2. Diane Rajaram
  3. Namgyal Dolker
  4. Joanna Mullen
  5. Dave Nisker
  6. Mercedes Perez
  7. Oriel Varga

We thank everyone for for supporting and attending this meeting. The meeting was a powerful and empowering example of communities and supporters coming together and asserting their collective power in the face of troubling suppression by the Board.

We look forward to continuing to work together to ensure the PCLS Board acknowledges and protects the right of clinic users and community members to decide how they should access their services, including legal clinics and legal aid.

Stay tuned for more updates about upcoming meetings!

Questions? Email as at concernedparkdale@gmail.com.